Merck’s Lawsuit Against Biden Administration

Pharmaceutical giant Merck has filed a lawsuit against the Biden administration, challenging a federal law that empowers Medicare to negotiate drug prices directly with manufacturers. The move, aimed at reducing drug costs for American seniors, has sparked a legal battle between the government and the pharmaceutical industry.

Merck's complaint argues that the law infringes on the company's free speech rights and violates the Fifth Amendment by forcing them to sell drugs at government-set prices.

Become a Subscriber

Please purchase a subscription to continue reading this article.

Subscribe Now

The Medicare medication negotiating program was established by Democrats as part of the Inflation Reduction Act, allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices with manufacturers. Beginning in 2026, Medicare will be able to negotiate prices for certain medications that have lacked generic competition.

Merck's popular type 2 diabetes drug, Januvia, is expected to be included in this list. Despite earning billions in revenue from Januvia, Merck argues that the law would limit its ability to invest in innovation and the development of novel medicines and treatments.

Merck's lawyers, representing the company at Jones Day, contend that the program violates the corporation's free speech rights and the Fifth Amendment.

They argue that the government-set pricing imposed by the law infringes upon Merck's ability to determine the prices of its products. While the law allows drugmakers to reject Medicare's final offer and pay a tax instead, Merck claims that the associated fee is excessive and would deprive them of ownership rights.

Supporters of the Medicare negotiation program view it as a crucial step toward reducing exorbitant drug prices in the United States. Advocates argue that the current system allows pharmaceutical companies to enjoy significant profits, particularly through Medicare, while patients struggle with high costs.

Cancer patient and founder of Patients For Affordable Drugs Now, David Mitchell, highlights that the negotiation framework incentivizes innovation and emphasizes the clinical value of drugs.

The Biden administration has stated its intention to vigorously defend the drug price negotiation law. Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Xavier Becerra has affirmed that the law is already reducing healthcare costs for seniors and people with disabilities.

However, Merck's lawsuit has faced criticism from healthcare and prescription drug advocates who accuse the company of prioritizing profits over patients' well-being.

The lawsuit filed by Merck against the Biden administration regarding the Medicare drug price negotiation program reflects the ongoing battle over the high cost of prescription drugs in the United States. As the legal proceedings unfold, the outcome of this lawsuit will have significant implications for drug pricing and the accessibility of medications for American seniors.