Berkshire Hathaway’s HomeServices Settles Antitrust Litigation, Reshaping Real Estate Commissions

Berkshire Hathaway's real estate brokerage, HomeServices of America, has reached a significant milestone in the realm of antitrust litigation. On April 26, 2024, the brokerage finalized a $250 million settlement in a nationwide case that is poised to redefine the structure of real estate agent compensation.

This settlement marks the conclusion of a lengthy legal battle against the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and four other brokerages, with HomeServices being the last remaining defendant. The litigation stemmed from allegations of collusion within the industry, particularly in regard to maintaining artificially high real estate commissions. A pivotal moment occurred in October 2023, when a jury in Kansas City, Missouri, ruled in favor of home sellers, awarding damages totaling $1.78 billion, potentially subject to tripling by a judge.

Become a Subscriber

Please purchase a subscription to continue reading this article.

Subscribe Now

The magnitude of potential liability prompted HomeServices to pursue settlement, eliminating the looming threat of a substantially higher payout. However, the agreement is contingent upon court approval, and responses from lawyers representing plaintiff sellers are pending.

This settlement is part of a broader legal landscape, wherein the NAR recently agreed to a $418 million settlement in nationwide antitrust litigation, a move that garnered preliminary approval from a judge. As a consequence of these settlements, the NAR and participating brokerages, including HomeServices of America and Re/Max, will collectively pay over $943 million to resolve antitrust claims.

Analysts anticipate significant changes in real estate commission structures as a result of these settlements. Specifically, revisions to payment rules for buyers' and sellers' agents are expected to yield commission reductions of at least 25%. Such adjustments could have profound implications for industry practices and market dynamics.

Notably, Berkshire Hathaway's involvement in the real estate sector extends beyond HomeServices. With ownership of 92% of Berkshire Hathaway Energy, the conglomerate wields influence across a spectrum of utilities, pipelines, and renewable energy projects. However, Berkshire Hathaway Energy remains embroiled in similar litigation in Kansas City, underscoring the broader legal challenges facing the conglomerate.

In response to inquiries, HomeServices spokesperson Chris Kelly clarified that the settlement represents a singular obligation of HomeServices, distinct from any involvement by its parent entity. Additionally, Berkshire Hathaway, under the stewardship of Warren Buffett, concluded 2023 with a formidable cash reserve totaling $167.60 billion, a testament to its financial strength and stability.

As the dust settles on these landmark settlements, the real estate industry braces for transformative changes in commission structures, propelled by legal interventions and regulatory scrutiny.